One of my favorite classics is Owen Wister's western novel "The Virginian," a tale of a rugged, unpolished frontier cowboy and the softening effect a "civilized" school ma'arm has on him. He is pitted against an Iago-like nemesis by the name of Trampas, who early in the book refers to the title character by a name that could be considered affectionate or contemptuous.
In a lethal voice, packing a gun loose in its holster, the Virginian tells him, "Smile when you call me that."
Indeed. The contempt resonating in our labels can be polarizing and demeaning.
You can call me lithe; you can call me slim; but please don't call me skinny. There's the fire of ridicule in at least one of those descriptions.
And so it is with words that, of themselves, suggest no more and no less than their meanings. I'm a liberal arts major, for instance. That means I've studied a broad range of courses in culture, language, literature, philosophy, and other subjects.
I'm pretty proud of being a liberal arts major. It's a description I like. But the word 'liberal' itself is much maligned, I fear.
In its purest sense, liberal means tolerant of different viewpoints, open-minded, progressive politically or socially. In its purest sense, conservative means favoring traditional values and customs, cautious and restrained, careful. Depending on who you are, there's something to admire in either, whichever way your inclinations and beliefs lead you. There's room for common ground if we happen to be of different minds.
But, I suggest, both terms have been co-opted and corrupted, serving whatever Pavlovian purposes their users intend. They've been put in a "wrong" and a "right" category, depending on your viewpoints. A "for" and "against" A "me" and "you." A "not on your life will I ever discuss this with you and really talk WITH you" corner.
Surely there's more room for dialog instead of diatribe. Surely we all have, buried somehwere deep inside us, just a little of the liberal arts instinct to analyze, weigh evidence, and see the possibilities for more than one interpretation.
But if not, I beg you this: whatever label you affix to me, smile when you call me that.